Bear River Meditation Group
Zen Buddhism Meditation Group
  • About
  • Retreats and Events
  • Weekly Meetings
  • Meditation
  • Dharma
    • Books
    • Articles
    • Dharma Series
  • Contacts
  • Links
  • Donations

Archive for Audio Dharma Talks

Talk Three: Unspoken Scriptures and Unsung Sutras and Our Practice by Reverend Helen Cummings

Posted by Pam Johnson 
· July 23, 2017 
· No Comments

This the third talk in a Dharma series called “Scriptures, Sutras, Invocations –  Chanted, Spoken, Unspoken”, prepared by Reverend Helen Cummings for the Bear River Meditation Group in July, 2017

Talk 3:  Unspoken Scriptures and Unsung Sutras and Our Practice

Books!  The printed page! And by extension, a well packaged audio presentation – YouTube or a TED talk – or even an inviting blog!  How much easier was it for me to give credence to “the truth” in this form.  The truth in the form of my boss or my partner or my own heart was often a lot less accessible.

A significant shift for me – a life changing event, actually – occurred when I made the choice to “read” and engage with The Sutra of My Boss, The Scripture of My Partner and The Mantra of My Own Heart.

Rooted in the experience of recited and sung scriptures, I was able to be present in body and mind in a nonjudgmental way – breathing deeply, attending deeply, engaging deeply.  Interactions with friends, enemies, or “just another face in the crowd” became liturgical events, the ceremonies of daily life.  In them – as in reciting or chanting – I didn’t have to prove anything.  As in singing or saying a simple verse,  I had nothing to fear or nothing to loose.  I had the opportunity to be present in the teaching of the other.

Sometimes that teaching was clear, and I could resonate with the easy access of it.  Sometimes the teaching made no sense and I could only sit in the presence of it, letting it be, appreciating what I could.  But just as in a ceremony or at the stoplight, when I recited or sang a verse or a scripture or an invocation, I was still able to breathe – and thereby make space for – something larger than myself.

May I repeat what Rev. Master Daishin Morgan underscored:   “As scriptures are sung or recited, one cannot ponder the meaning in the way one can when reflecting on them with the intellect…  Some situations, some people, we just can’t figure out.  We do not necessarily come away from (chanting) having learned something.  One lets go of being an observer and becomes a total participant.  Yes, I can be present in myself in the
presence of the other without fear or judgment or expectation.

Isn’t this the real meaning of sympathy?  As Dogen says

If one can identify oneself with that which is not oneself,

One can understand the true meaning of sympathy…

…Sympathy is as the sea in that it never refuses water
from whatsoever source it may come;

All waters may gather and form only one sea.

Rev. Master Jiyu teaches that we are all celebrants in the ceremony of daily life.  And as celebrant we are not separate.  We are connected to all we meet in our day, just as when  we stand on the bowing seat, we stand for the whole community.  Monk or lay person, we always have the opportunity to spread our mat wider.

Daily life is our ground of training.  Great Master Dogen in the Shobogenzo says that  “…the Great Enlightenment is synonymous with our tea and meals.”  In The Rules for Meditation he says clearly:  …there is only one thing, to train hard for this is true enlightenment; training and enlightenment are naturally undefiled; to live in this way is the same as to live an ordinary daily life.  The koan DOES appear naturally in daily life.  The Genjo-Koan, the koan of everyday-life, is our fundamental scripture.  How do we recite or chant the Genjo-Koan, especially on “one of those days”?

Each being that I encounter is a scripture.  Each person that crosses my path on any given day is an invocation.  Each of those colleagues or friends that I take for granted is a mantra.  When I encounter a living scripture, am I able to make space for the truth of the other?  I may not understand but, just as in our meditation practice, I can allow the unsettling or the uncertain to be there – to arise, to abide, and to pass away.

In singing an invocation, I know I can give voice to meaningful truth.  Can I do this when I encounter The Scripture of the Other in my daily life?

In reciting a mantra, I know to let go of that which constrains and tightens my breath.  Can I let go of that which constrains and tightens in my relationships in daily life?

When I hold on too tightly to my self, to my agenda, to my image, I can’t sing in the full voice that John Wesley encourages.  My breath becomes shallow.  I loose touch with my hara and with the mind of meditation.  Reciting, chanting, singing – all are so valuable bring me back to the breath and – with the breath – to the mind of mediation.

When I refrain from harshness I can better appreciate The Sutra of Each Being.  As Dogen describes another of the Four Wisdoms

To behold all beings with the eye of compassion

And to speak kindly to them, is the meaning of tenderness…

…Whenever one speaks kindly to another his face brightens
and his heart is warmed;

If a kind word be spoken in his absence, the impression will be a deep one;

Tenderness can have a revolutionary impact upon the mind of man.

Speaking with tenderness is speaking in the mind of meditation.  Tenderness is a reflection of that deeper breathing that is rooted in practice, in awareness.

When I express gratitude I can more clearly hear The Sutra of Each Situation.  When I can accept the differences and the changes that are part
of my daily life I can more clearly see the Buddha’s Truth and see what needs to be done.

If one creates wise ways of helping beings,
whether they be in high places or lowly stations,

one exhibits benevolence…

…The stupid believe that they will lose something if they give help to others,

But this is completely untrue for benevolence helps everyone,
including oneself,

Being a law of the universe.

In chanting I am more alert to the possibilities of harmonization with “the other”, whether it’s the unison harmony of one accord, the pleasant harmony of easy blending or the clashing harmony of discord (dis-chord).  There is room in the flow of the “invocation of daily life” for all of these.  And, as RM Jiyu says in Music Is Zen, there are no mistakes in music.

In fact, as organist for our community, I’ve enjoyed participating in conferences of The Hymn Society, a delightful assembly of church musicians, composers, and text writers from throughout the United States and Canada.  I once asked several of the participating organists what they did when they made a mistake in their accompaniments.  Without exception they responded that they would play “it” – the mistake – they’d play it again,
putting it into the context of the music itself, deliberately weaving it in melodically, tonally.  They weren’t afraid of an “unexpected note” as one talented organist called it.  “Those unexpected notes opened doors for me.” she said.

I remind myself that chanting and reciting are NOT about performance.  And
neither is my engagement with the Scriptures of Daily Life.  Performance is subject to reviews, to evaluation, to judgment.  Performance is looking to achieve something. Chanting, on the other hand, is an offering “without strings” or ulterior motives.  Can I just be with someone without an agenda?  Can I just do what needs to be done?  Can I just keep the Precepts?

When we just do this, we’re acting with true generosity, true charity.  Again, Dogen says

Charity is the opposite of covetousness;

We make offerings although we ourselves get nothing whatsoever.

There is no need to be concerned about how small the gift may be
so long as it brings true results for,
even if it is only a single phrase or verse of  teaching,
it may be a seed to bring forth  good fruit both now and here after.

In the Shobogenzo, Dogen says that “…the willingness to see clearly, without judgments or expectations, results in the emergence of True Practice.”  I sometimes read that last lines as “…results in the emergence of True Enlightenment.”  Remember?  Training and enlightenment are one and the same.  So I can read it this way:  my willingness to see clearly, without judgments or expectations results in the emergence of True Enlightenment.  When we train, we are enlightened.  And the signs of enlightenment are enlightened actions – when we act with charity, or tenderness, benevolence, sympathy, when we act with the Four Wisdoms.

Performance sets up opposites and, as Dogen says, when the opposites arise, the Buddha Mind is lost.  Chanting invites us to a visceral understanding of one voice in the many and the many voices emerging as one.  We breathe as one.  We practice as one.

Performance requires an audience.  Chanting, ceremonial, is rooted always in the “temple of our own hearts”.  May we not only dwell in the temple of our own hearts, amidst the myriad mountains, but may we sit at ease therein and offer heart-mind-opening chant and space-making ceremonial.

I’d like to read Dogen’s reflections on his own practice from the Shobogenzo Chapter 82 Shukke Kudoku.  He says

I sit at ease within the forest grove.
Tranquilly, my human failings are overthrown.

     Through being impartial, I attain a singleness of mind,
the pleasure of which surpasses the pleasures of celestial realms.
Others may seek to gain wealth and honor,
or fineries of dress or comfortable abodes,
but such pleasures lack true peace, since for one in pursuit of gains,
there is no satiety.  Adorned in my patched robe, I go forth begging my food.
Whether moving or standing still, I am always one within my heart.
With my very own Eye of Wise Discernment,
I fathom the True Nature of all thoughts and things.
Within the sundry gates to the Dharma,
I enter only to see that all are just alike,
So this Heart that understands The Way of things is tranquil,
for there is nothing that can surpass It within the triple world.

Lay person or monk, our practice is one of accepting what is placed in our begging bowl in terms of health, relationship, work or any of life’s offerings.  Lay person or monk, whether moving or standing still, we can always be one within our own hearts.  Lay person or monk, with our very own Eyes of Wise Discernment, we can choose to fathom the True Nature of all thoughts and things, truly seeking that which brings Abiding Peace.

Performance has a start and a finish.  Chant is an on-going, “every-minute meditation.  Each breath is the fundamental chant.  And we can return to it in conscious and unconscious acts of faith and mindfulness.

What effect did your encounter with this scripture have?  How did you participate in it?  What impact does this encounter have on your practice?   And how does it support your practice?

Thank you to all who have listened to this talk – and to the two preceding talks in this series.  Please contact me through the Bear River Meditation Group website if you have any questions about the material therein.

And please do explore the references, both printed and audio.

And most of all, please do find time in your practice to recite, to chant, and to sing, all the while offering gratitude to Rev. Master Jiyu for her legacy of Scriptures, Sutras, Invocations – Chanted, Spoken, and Unspoken, and exploring further the many ways that these scriptures, sutras and invocations enrich and support our practice.

I offer the merit of this Dharma Talk for the benefit of all beings,
known and unknown, in need of merit.
Homage to the Buddha.  Homage to the Dharma.  Homage to the Sangha.


No Comments
Categories : Articles, Audio Dharma Talks, Class Series, Uncategorized

Talk Two: Sung Scriptures, Litanies, Invocations and Our Practice by Reverend Helen Cummings

Posted by Pam Johnson 
· July 16, 2017 
· No Comments

This is the second of three Dharma offerings in the series Scriptures, Sutras, Invocations –  Chanted, Spoken, Unspoken by Reverend Helen Cummings, a Senior Teacher of Buddhism at Shasta Abbey Buddhist Monastery. The text version of the teaching is below.

Link to Audio

Talk 2: Sung Scriptures, Litanes, Invocations and Our Practice

For centuries the monks of a Benedictine monastery in France had chanted the Divine Office 8 times every day, even getting up at 3am to sing the Night Offices. Some members of the monastic community decided that this amount of singing was a waste of time so at a certain point in the 1960s they decided to give up their chanting.  They’d been tired all the time, and thought it was because of lack of sleep as they got up for the Night Offices.  The monks started to sleep through the night, yes, but the more they slept, the more tired they became.  There was also a significant increase in bickering among the monks.  They became listless and fatigued. Even when their schedule was further altered to allow more sleep, they were constantly weary.  A change in diet was implemented but the monks’ health did not improve.

Then Dr. Alfred Tomatis, a noted voice and hearing specialist, visited the monastery.   He found 70 out of 90 monks were bedridden or in their cells, completely exhausted, incapable of completing their religious duties.  After investigating,  Dr. Tomatis suggested to the Abbot of the monastery – quite counterintuitively – that the monks start singing the offices again.
And in fact, in just a few months, the monastery came back to life.  Of those 70 weakened or debilitated monks, 68 got back their energy for singing, for thinking, for living their monastic vocation.  When the monks resumed singing, harmony in their day-to-day relations was restored as well.

Dr. Tomatis concludes:  “Clearly singing is important.  It energizes the singer as well as the listener…we can never sing too much, any more than we can listen to music too often.
It is critical, however, to clarify which kind of music and singing nurtures us
.”

Singing matters.  And  sacred music makes a significant difference in religious practice.  Rev. Master Jiyu knew this.  In this talk I hope to address some of the ways her legacy of chanting supports us in our practice.

Rev. Master Jiyu knew what the ancestors and traditions that go all the way back to the Buddha knew:  that music unlocks the scriptures and teaching in ways that the intellect can not.  It opens our hearts in ways that will alone does not.

So, she set ten major Buddhist scriptures, twelve major litanies, numerous offertories, mantras, dedications, and the Homages to music.  She created nearly 70 invocations that we sing throughout our liturgical year. She also laid the foundation for us to continue to create new invocations, mantras, and processionals, either setting scriptures and text to the hymn tunes of past
and the present or writing our own music . She left the cultural aspects of practice in Japan, and she brought the heart of Zen to us in the West. In literally translating the Scriptures, and in creating the ceremonial forms for their use, she understood clearly that Western chants and hymn tunes ARE the religious music of the West and would allow much greater access to the teaching.  We don’t chant in Japanese.  We don’t chant in the Japanese style of percussive monotone.
In doing this she did what Buddhism says you do:  put the Scriptures –  invocations and all forms of teaching – in a language that people can understand, although there is a tradition to keep mantras in Sanskrit.  In the Buddha’s time monks were not allowed to chant the Buddhist Dharma in classical Sanskrit.  There is the story about the two monks, former Brahmins, very well-educated who complained to the Buddha that people were using bad grammar when they chant Sanskrit.  The Buddha said NO to
their request to have people chant in “proper” Sanskrit.  He said the Dharma had to be taught in the language of those to whom it is being taught.

And so we sing in English.   And we sing using the resonances of western sacred music.  Rev. Master Jiyu chose plainsong and Anglican chants because they provide the means of supporting sacred text without getting in the way of the words.  In putting words and music together, she used plainsong – with its single line of melody – for offertories, dedications, and some hymns; she used  Anglican chant – with its lovely 4-part harmonies -for Scriptures, and litanies. And she drew on the wealth of the Christian hymnbooks and her own creativity to find both musical and textual vessels for Buddhist hymns that express gratitude, praise, invocation, or tell a story.  She drew on the tradition that sings the names of the Buddhas, or the Bodhisattvas, or the Ancestors.  And she did this with |a broad ecumenical spirit drawing from Catholic, Methodists, Russian Orthodox and the Church of England traditions.

Buddhism originally developed within an oral culture, and as an oral tradition.  Music in the Northern Indian culture where the Buddha lived was highly developed, both for secular ceremonial use and for religious purposes.  Chanting was a means of memorizing religious texts.  From the time of the Buddha, and before, religious practitioners chanted to remember what is important and to pass it along the those that would come after.  In chanting we can remember what is important and “have it” when we need it.

Whether chanting the name of Buddha, or repeating a particular mantra, or singing an extended scripture like The Surangama Sutra, monks and laity alike are invited to “…read, recite, write down, remember…”  We do these things in order to become what is read, recited, written down, remembered.  Thus chanting has both a transformative
purpose and a transformative effect!

When we chant, our faith grows.  When we chant, we open our hearts and minds to that which is larger than ourselves.  Rev. Master Jiyu said, “…chanting is portable meditation.”  She knew that when we chant we go beyond our discriminative thoughts.  When we chant we’re less likely to judge, to assess, or to expect.  Rev. Master Jiyu was clear:  “…singing and chanting are taking meditation from the cushion and into the ceremony hall…” or to another form of our “moving meditation” in the Ceremony
of Daily Life.  She explained our monastic schedule this way:  first we sit and meditate in the Meditation Hall.  Immediately following that we have Morning Service – with bows and breath.  The bows open us to that which is larger than ourselves.  The breath brings body and mind together.  Bringing the mind back to our breath is our ceaseless practice.  Vocal sound is audible breath, and in the sounds of chanting we begin and end with the breath.  We breathe deeply, for we need robust columns of vibrating air to support our chant.  But we also breathe deeply in chanting because this breath is itself rooted in the hara, our sitting place.  The Sufi poet, Kabir, asks a telling question:  “Tell me, what is God?   He is the breath inside the breath.”

As in all things in Buddhism, it’s the attitude of mind that is the heart of any chanting, singing or ceremony.  When we chant we ARE NOT performing.  Whatever the form -single note chanting or singing an organ-accompanied four-part harmony invocation –  the form itself always embodies of the mind of meditation.  The monks at Eiheiji, describing their chanting, noted that  “…(the chants) are not meant to hypnotize participants into apathy.  The mind should become quite clear, receptive, so that it may know what is beyond concepts and beneath activities.  In this experiencemind and body must both participate.”
Chanting is a means of “cooling down our active mind” as Barisheba describes in the Shobogenzo chapter “Ceaseless Practice”.  The mind gives way to the breath.  And the breath deepens.

Body and mind ARE one as Dogen says and chanting enhances that mind-body connection. Chant has real impact on our physical well being as the Benedictine monks earlier found out.  It has the ability to impact consciousness.  Chanting supports insight as the mind relaxes its grip.  It opens our hearts and lifts our spirits.  Webster’s Dictionary says that “healing is to make sound”.  I love the double meanings here!

Chanting creates sacred space.  Someone said that our voice is a cathedral!  When we sing, we listen, both to ourselves and to others.  I am reminded of one form of the
Homages that says

I take refuge in the Sangha, wishing that all sentient beings
shall be able to live in harmony,
as well as harmonized the general multitude,
without any obstruction whatsoever,
and that all shall respect the sacred Sangha.

Chanting also allows for what Ajahn Amaro, in his book Inner Listening  calls “the sound of silence” or “the nada sound”.  I find it interesting that Nada is the Sanskrit word for “sound” as well as being the Spanish word  for “nothing”.  Music without rests or pauses simply becomes noise.

And at the same time chanting embraces activity and engagement.  We sing with the paramita of Vigor.  Conversely, we can use singing to strengthen Vigor within ourselves when we feel we’re lacking it!  We sing not only with the mind of meditation but with the body of meditation.  We engage with the music, AND we engage with the surrounding Sangha – the “choir of daily life”.  I’ll never forget the moment on the day after I’d entered the monastic community as a postulant when I stood with the community – in the midst of monks – for the first time for Morning Service.  The chanting was an altogether different experience, a far cry from “sitting on the sidelines”.  I was present in the sound.  I participated in each breath in a very different way.  That experience affirmed my intention “…to be able to live in harmony.”

When we chant, we change our relationship to the scriptures or litanies that we sing.  We experience the words of an invocation in a different way when we sing them.  Our thinking process shifts as we breathe the musical line of the scriptures.  Our breathing changes – deepens – as we repeat a mantra over and over again.

The word mantra originally meant sacred sounds that communicate through vibration to inspire and open the heart rather than the mind.  Sacred sounds, Buddhist “music” indeed does that very thing. Our fundamental practice is the harmonization of body and mind. This might be said to be one “goal” of the practice of chanting.  Indeed, those of you who know the Benedictine tradition will recognize this as being quite in line with St. Benedict’s Rule that says “…let us sing in such a way that our minds are in harmony with our voices.”

Kusala Bhikkhu, a long-time friend of the Abbey says that “…Zen pretty much comes down to three things: everything changes, everything is connected, and pay attention. “ I’d like to make the case that chanting seems to lead us to the same conclusion.  Music is constantly moving; it’s inherently connective; and requires breath-by-breath attention.  Even the “rests” in our singing are energized.

So the practice of chanting provides a significant support of our meditation practice.  How would I compare meditation and chanting?   One definition of chant is “sung speech”, as I’ve said before.  But may I suggest that chant is also “audible meditation”.  In meditation and chanting, breath is deeply significant.  In both we have the opportunity to let go of “mistakes” or judgments. Both meditation and chanting reinforce our connection with
others when we sit or when we sing together. Both engage the whole body – sitting up straight – or standing or lying down, with feet firmly on the ground, breathing deeply and from the hara.  Both chanting and meditating are offerings, neither is a performance.  Both are done “without strings”.  As Rev. Master Jiyu says in Music Is Zen, both music and singing teach us there are no mistakes, only opportunities to learn and to do what needs to be done.

Chanting is often a means of preparing the mind for meditation, as well as for carrying that mediation practice into the rest of our daily lives.  Whether a lay person or a monk, chanting allows us to bring to mind the teachings of the Buddha or to offer praise or to reflect on and remember aspects of the teaching or of the Bodhisattvas.  Chanting is a means of expressing gratitude. It is a means both of being present AND of actively participating in the mind of meditation.

Chant is a way to get a community to breathe together.  No wonder those Benedictines saw a decrease in bickering once they started singing again.  St. Benedict said you can tell much about a community by the way it sings.  Think of the “chants of identity” at a baseball game – an energized crowd is often considered to be “the Tenth Man” for the home team.   Think about the “chants of protest” that have become all too frequent at recent Black Lives Matter marches.

To paraphrase Rev. Master Daishin Morgan in his article The Role of Ceremonies:  “As scriptures are sung or recited, one cannot ponder the meaning in the way one can when reflecting on them with the intellect…We do not necessarily come away from (chanting) having learned something.  One lets go of being an observer and becomes a total participant.  This is what chanting teaches us in support of our practice – to let go of being an observer, to become a total participant.

Rev. Master Daishin Morgan also notes that “No ceremony (or chanting! my paraphrase) is necessary and no one’s enlightenment depends upon a ceremony (or chanting!  my paraphrase), but as we go deeper in training there is less and less distinction between ceremonies (or chanting! my paraphrase) and any other aspect of life.  Ceremonies (or chanting! my paraphrase) may start out as a form that points to awakening, but gradually we come to realize the nature of practice that never ceases and is no longer practice at all.  Enlightenment really is in this moment, and life is its
expression.”

Let me read that again:  “No chanting is necessary and no one’s enlightenment depends upon chanting, but as we go deeper in training there is less and less distinction between chanting and any other aspect of life.  Chanting may start out as a form that points to awakening, but gradually we come to realize the nature of practice that never ceases and is no longer practice at all.  Enlightenment really is in this moment, and life is its expression.”

The teachings of the Buddha mention music on many occasions.  The Buddha, in fact, made use of  the simile of the lute in his teaching on right effort.  In music, as in life, nothing should ever be in excess. Music keeps the right beat, neither too fast nor too slow, following the breath, keeping the right measure.  We do exactly the same when we meditate or when we practice with the mind of meditation.  Our practice is the practice of the Middle Way, as Dogen describes it, “…the correct ordering of daily life. “

In the Amitabha Sutra, it is written that heavenly singing and chanting there is heard all day and all night as mandara flowers rain down from the heavens.  And on hearing these melodies, those present naturally become mindful of the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha.  In accordance, it says, all Buddhas and Bodhisattvas are very skilled in utilizing music to spread the Dharma and to guide sentient beings to enlightenment.

Sutras sung as hymns and other songs praising the virtues of the Buddhas have attracted and helped purify the hearts of countless disciples.  The Buddha’s Teaching on the Perfection of Great Wisdom says “In order to build a pure land, the bodhisattvas make use of beautiful music to soften people’s hearts.  With their hearts softened, people’s minds are more receptive, and thus easier to educate and transform through the teachings.  For this reason, music has been established as one type of ceremonial offering to be made to the Buddha.”  The Mahavairochana Sutra says “in all acts of singing there is truth; every dance portrays reality.”

So yes!  may we be profoundly grateful to Rev. Master Jiyu!  Chanting truly supports our practice.  The words of our scriptures, invocations, songs, mantras – all offer rich teaching.  And there is also something beyond discriminative thought in the music that underlies them.  And that combination of music and words together serve as a doorway to that “…deepest Wisdom of the heart that is beyond discriminative thought…”.

May we choose to go through that doorway.

In the coming week, perhaps you might pick one scripture, or an invocation, or a mantra and make a commitment to sing it out load each day.

Or perhaps you might sing your practice in a way that resonates with you and make a commitment to do it daily.

What impact does this have on your practice?  How does it support your practice?
I offer the merit of this Dharma Talk for the benefit of all beings,
known and unknown, in need of merit.
Homage to the Buddha.  Homage to the Dharma.  Homage to the Sangha.

No Comments
Categories : Articles, Audio Dharma Talks, Class Series

Talk One: Recited Scriptures and Our Practice by Rev. Helen Cummings

Posted by Pam Johnson 
· July 10, 2017 
· No Comments

This is the first of three Dharma offerings in the series Scriptures, Sutras, Invocations –  Chanted, Spoken, Unspoken by Reverend Helen Cummings, a Senior Teacher of Buddhism at Shasta Abbey Buddhist Monastery. The text version of the teaching is below.    Link to Audio.

Talk 1:  Recited Scriptures and Our Practice 
The Scripture on the Immeasurable Life of the Tathagata, one of the core scriptures of our Tradition, begins like this

The World-Honored One (the Buddha), then desiring to reiterate the Teaching’s meaning, spoke thus in verse:
Since I have realized Buddhahood, the aeons through which I have passed are immeasurable hundreds of thousands of millions of billions.
Continuously have I voice the Dharma, teaching untold billions of beings how to turn their hearts around that they might enter the Buddha’s path.

The Buddha himself says it—he continuously voices the Dharma! So what is “voicing the Dharma”?   For our purposes here it is speaking the Dharma, or chanting (which is often defined as “sung speech”) the Dharma, or acting in accord with the Dharma in our daily lives.  Rev. Master Jiyu built on the Buddha’s example, leaving us a legacy that helps us take our meditation practice right from our sitting place into all aspects of daily life.Reverend Master Jiyu’s liturgical legacy—of Scriptures, Sutras, Verses – all of this supports our practice and encourages our fuller participate in what she called “the Ceremony of Daily Life”. In this and the next two talks I hope to address how this liturgical legacy supports us in our practice.

Recitation of scriptures and verses is not limited to being a monk at Shasta Abbey or on retreat.  This is a practice that fits the monastery, the home, the office, school, hospital and recreation area.  Whether a lay person or a monk we all have the opportunity to bring greater commitment, mindfulness, gratitude and kindness to our daily practice.   As a lay person I found that one on the most helpful moments in a busy day in Silicon Valley traffic day was the opportunity to recite the Invocation of Achalanatha at the
3-minute long stoplights along the San Tomas Express.

This is a practice for all people, in all places. Reciting scriptures in our tradition—speaking them aloud—is an essential part of our practice.  The scriptures and verses we recite throughout our day become our meditation cushion away from our seats.  We act as a Buddha when we keep the Precepts.  And we act as a Buddha when we give voice to the Dharma.  Recitation throughout our day continuously brings us back to our meditation cushion, even the recitation of a single word.  We stop.  We return to the “temple of our own heart”, just as we might go to the Meditation Hall.  To stop to recite a verse, a mantra, even a short phrase, is to come back to our sitting place.

Recitations of a longer scriptures are an acts of mindfulness. Recitations of the short verses can help us strengthen awareness in our daily activities.  They can open and deepen our experience of simple acts which we often take for granted. When we focus our mind on the verse, we return to ourselves and become more aware of each action. What do I do when the phone rings?  Is it a bell – inviting me to deeper meditation and awareness?   What needs to be done right now?  What is happening right now?  What is the verse that might be helpful in this very situation?  At this very moment?

Recitation is a means of bringing together body and mind.  It is a means of putting thoughts into our body – embodying them – using breath, vocal chords, tongue, lips, and ears.  Recitation is the means we have of expressing charity, tenderness, benevolence sympathy, Dharma through our lungs, throat and mouth.  Recitation is an act of commitment to our practice, actually saying something out loud, and hearing ourselves say it, perhaps listening to others.  We act as witnesses for ourselves and for others when we do this.   This is one expression of making a vow – “…I vow to make the Buddha’s Truth one with myself…” in this very real embodied way.

Recitation strengthens our connection with our own Buddha Nature as we give voice to the descriptions and reflections of – Buddha Nature.  That’s what the scriptures give us.

Recitation is an act of faith.  As it says in The Scripture on the Immeasurable Life of the Tathagata  ‘…for the Buddha’s Words are true,

not something that is empty and vain…”  The same Scripture continues “…I know at all times whether a sentient being is treading the

Path or walks in other ways, and according to what needs to be done to aid that one, voice teachings of various kinds, making for each this my intention:  ‘how may I help this being enter the Unsurpassed Way and quickly realize Buddahood…’ ”  This is the fundamental expression of the Bodhisattva Vow.

Recitation is a means we have to give vocal energy to Truth, bringing our uninterrupted meditation to life in both senses of that phrase.  Recitation is a means we have to express gratitude. How can we not offer merit for all beings?  Recitation is a means we have of strengthening our own practice, wherever we are, in whatever situations we find ourselves.

Tradition starts the day with a meditation period.  And that first meditation period concludes with the Kesa Verse:
How great and wondrous are the Clothes of Enlightenment,
Formless and embracing every treasure.
I wish to unfold the Buddha’s Teaching,
That I may help all living things.
This verse expresses our wish, not only to practice through the next 24 hours, but in that practice to fulfill the Bodhisattva Vow “…That I may help all living things”. Whether we put on a kesa or a wagesa or simply articulate the words, we set the tone for how we  practice this one day – today.  We recite the Three Refuges at the end of the day, as The Scripture of Brahma’s Net urges:  “at night as you concentrate your mind, keep the Three Treasures in your thoughts…”.  We take refuge in the Buddha. We take refuge in the Dharma.  We take refuge in the  Sangha, choosing to focus on the One True Thing as we go to sleep, letting go of the distractions of the day.
In between these bookends to our day there are so many opportunities for recitation in daily life, both the formal and informal.

We can organize our lives to have time to do formal recitations of Short Morning Service or the Surangama Litany, or say some part of the Mealtime Ceremonial before a meal.  And we can bring our awareness to the times in our day when we have the opportunity to recite the less formal “long stoplight” kinds verses.
The formal Soto Zen scriptures and verses are rich resources for us, both to recite and to study.  We are very lucky to have the traditional verses in English.  This, too, is part of Rev. Master Jiyu’s legacy.  Her translations – and those of Rev. Master Hubert Nearman – make these texts much more accessible to us.

At Shasta Abbey we express gratitude when we recite the Mealtime Ceremonial in one form or another at each meal, and I know lay friends who start a meal at a restaurant with them, too.  Whether in the more extended and formal Mealtime Ceremonial or in the shorter Donors’ Verse and the Five Thoughts we have the opportunity to express our gratitude and our purpose for accepting this food.

The Donors’ Verse says
The two kinds of alms, material and spiritual,
have the endowment of boundless merit.
Now that they have been fulfilled in this act of charity,
both self and others gain pleasure there from.
The Five Thoughts go on
We must think deeply of the ways and means by which this food has come.

We must consider our merit when accepting it.

We must protect ourselves from error by excluding greed from our minds.

We will eat lest we become lean and die.

We accept this food so that we may become enlightened.

We can also say the Donor’s Verse when we receive anything, not just food.  It’s an acknowledgement of our gratitude and our connection to all beings: …both self and other gains pleasure there from.  Similarly we can say the Five Thoughts when we receive a teaching, or a gift, or a hard and uncomfortable truth:
…the ways and means this difficulty has come…
…can I consider my merit when accepting it…?
…can I protect myself from error by excluding greed from my mind?
…can I accept it lest I become lean and die (metaphorically or otherwise)?
…and can I accept this teaching so that I may become enlightened?

When we sit to study the Dharma we recite the Lecture Verse as I did at the start of this talk.
The unsurpassed, penetrating and perfect Truth is seldom met with
Even in a hundred thousand myriad kalpas.

Now we can see and hear it.  We can remember and accept it.

I vow to make the Buddha’s Truth one with myself.

Here again, we have the opportunity to commit ourselves to deepen our practice as we vow to make the Buddha’s Truth one with myself.

When we step into challenging situations the Metta Sutra or the Loving Kindness Sutra comes to hand.  May all beings be happy, peaceful, and free from suffering.  This goes a long way toward diffusing situations of difficulty, tension, and anger – whether outside me or in my own heart.

When we go shopping, or turn on the TV set or connect to the internet, or are in a situation where we’ve just “gotta have it” we have Venerable Heng Sure’s VegSource Mantra:

I have enough.  I am grateful.  Share the blessing, BodhiSvaha
I have enough.  I am grateful.  Share the blessing, BodhiSvaha.

When we recite the Surangama Sutra we ask for help from the Buddhas and Ancestors.  It is possible to organize our lives so that we can recite regularly the whole of the Scripture and we can also read small segments of it as is possible.  I have come to value the following verses from The Surangama in my own practice:

Make known what needs to be known.
Tame those who would prolong pain. (p. 60   The Monastic Office)
or

To all that is difficult to look upon, Peace! (p. 67   The Monastic Office)
or

To the one who resists, Peace! (p. 68   The Monastic Office)
May you may find your own resonating mantras, verses and phrases as you recite this profound and subtle Surangama Litany.

When we renew our commitment to the Bodhisattva Way of practice we recite the  Bodhisattva Vows:

However innumerable beings may be, I vow to save them all.
However inexhaustible the passions may be, I vow to transform them all.
However limitless the Dharma may be, I vow to comprehend it completely..
However infinite the Buddha’s Truth is, I vow to realize it.

That “all” – all beings, all passions, all Dharmas, all Truths – all of them start in the moment right in front of me in my day-to-day life.  And whether  monk or a lay person our practice is the practice of the Bodhisattva Vow.  We’re part of the Mahayana Tradition.
The unsurpassed penetrating and perfect Truth is seldom met
with even in a hundred thousand myriad kalpas.
Now we can see and hear it.  We can remember and accept it.
I vow to make the Buddha’s Truth one with myself.

Dogen’s Rules for Meditation offer a doorway into a much deeper understanding of our meditation practice.  And I turn to the Rules when I find myself questioning or doubtful.  “Why ARE training and Enlightenment differentiated?”  “Why study the means of attaining it since the Supreme Teaching is free?”  It helps me to realize that even Great Master Dogen had questions.  We strengthen our commitment to the Precepts and practice when we recite the Shushogi. It contains rich teaching on the Precepts, contrition and conversion, the Four Wisdoms, and gratitude.  Whether the whole scripture or a single chapter or a short verse – this teaching is directly related to our daily life.
We turn the stream of compassion within when we recite the Invocation of Achalanatha (who, remember, is a manifestation of Great Compassion!).  I will often recite “…may I within the temple of my own hearts dwell amidst the myriad mountains,,,” when I am pulled in too many directions by too many distractions.
There are times when a “simple” mantra is enough—sometimes familiar words like Seek To Get Back On The Path (from the Parinirvana Scripture), repeated over and over again, give me encouragement.  Other times untranslated words like the Mantra of Kshtigarbha speak to something that is deeper in my heart.  Om Ha Ha Ha Vismaye Svaha!

Coming out of the drought in Northern California when I turn on the water faucet I very much appreciate “the ways and means” by which this water has come.  Before turning on the engine of the car I’m taking on a trip, I prepare for my journey by reciting a verse for starting the car.  I like one adapted from Ven Thich Nhat Hanh:  Before starting the car I know where I am going.  Or as I drive out the gate, I’ll say the Invocation for the Removal of Disasters.  There are so many opportunities for this kind of verse – turning on (or off) a light or a faucet or a computer, cleaning the bathroom or clearing the weeds – every single point in our day is our meditation cushion.

Reciting even a single word is a connection to our meditation practice – sometimes a simple Help is all I can manage, but it connects me with the Buddhas and the Ancestors.  It connects me with my meditation cushion.

And sometimes, the only thing that’s possible is a simple breath.  Etty Hillesum, author of An Interrupted Life, observed:  “…Sometimes the most important thing in a whole day is the rest we take between two deep breaths…” simply making the space to return to the mind of meditation.

When we recite a Scripture, a Sutra, and Invocation, a Verse, that recitation resounds with a fundamental YES!   YES! It is our intention to realize (make real!) the words we articulate.  YES!  We are committed to bring charity, tenderness, benevolence and sympathy, all forms of the Dharma into our “ceaseless practice”.  YES, as Dogen says  “…the Great Enlightenment is synonymous with our tea and meals.”

My teacher wrote on the back of my small kesa something I read each time I put it on.  “…To become Buddha is to behave like Buddha…”.  So, yes! it is my intention to “…continuously voice the Dharma…” .  I invite you to consider strengthening your practice through engaging more fully with this part of Rev. Master Jiyu’s legacy.

In the coming week, perhaps you might pick one scripture or verse in our tradition to recite on a regular basis.

Or you might consider creating your own verse to recite in your day, for example:
-the verse of the problem I have right now
-the verse of patience
-the verse of burrs under my saddle
-the verse of my commitment
-the verse of my practice

What impact does it have?  How does this recitation support your practice?

I offer the merit of this Dharma Talk for the benefit of all beings,
known and unknown, in need of merit.
Homage to the Buddha.  Homage to the Dharma.  Homage to the Sangha.

No Comments
Categories : Articles, Audio Dharma Talks, Class Series

Practicing the Dharma by Rev. Helen Cummings

Posted by Pam Johnson 
· March 9, 2015 
· 1 Comment

The following text was written in preparation for an audio Dharma talk, the fourth talk given for the Bear River Meditation Group class series in February/March 2015 on The Four Practices of Bodhidharma. The audio file of Reverend Helen’s talk is available here. Reverend Helen is a Zen monk training at Shasta Abbey Buddhist Monastery. She will respond to questions and discussion on the talk through the end of March 2015. Please scroll down to the end of the text to post your questions in the “Leave a Comment/Reply” area.  Responses will be moderated to eliminate spam and inappropriate language.

Practicing the Dharma
by Reverend Helen Cummings

The fourth of Bodhidharma’s Four Practices is practicing the Dharma, also given as union with the Dharma or accordance with the Dharma or enlightenment proved.

Dharma means the truth of things as they are, the truth that all natures are pure…

As Bodhidharma says:
The Dharma is the truth that all natures are pure.
By this truth, all appearances are empty.
Defilement and attachment, subject and object don’t exist.
The sutra says”The Dharma includes no being
because it’s free from the impurity of being,
and the Dharma includes no self
because it’s free from the impurity of self.”
Those wise enough to believe and understand these truths
are bound to practice according to the Dharma.
And since that which is real includes nothing
that is worth begrudging,
they give their body, life, and property in charity,
without regret, without the vanity of the giver, gift, or recipient,
and without bias or attachment.
And to eliminate impurity they teach others,
but without being attached to form.
Thus, through their own practice they’re able to help others
and glorify the Way of Enlightenment.
And as with charity, they practice the other virtues to eliminate delusion,
they practice nothing at all.
This is what is meant by practicing the Dharma.

The Fourth of the Four Noble Truths is that the cessation of suffering is possible through the Eightfold Path…a practical toolbox for aligning ourselves with the Dharma, with things as they are.  Through the steps on the Eightfold Path we address the causes of suffering in our lives.

The Fourth of Bodhidharma’s Practices – practicing the Dharma – addresses the fundamental question of our Buddhist life:  how do we practice the truth of how things really are?  how do we “prove enlightenment” – to find enlightenment to be true for ourselves?  And how do we deepen the realization – the making real –  of the Dharma in our daily life?  In order
to address the causes of suffering in our lives…
In the first chapter of the Shushogi, Introduction -The Reason for Training, Dogen underscores the importance of this practice:

The most important question for all Buddhists is how to understand birth and death completely for then, should you be able to find the Buddha within birth and death, they both vanish. All you have to do is realise that birth and death, as such, should not be avoided and they will cease to exist for then, if you can understand that birth and death are Nirvana itself, there is not only no necessity to avoid them but also nothing to search for that is called Nirvana. The understanding of the above breaks the chains that bind one to birth and death therefore this problem, which is the greatest in all Buddhism, must be completely understood.

“…if you can understand that birth and death are Nirvana itself, there is not only no necessity to avoid them but also nothing to search for that is called Nirvana…”  Understanding that this very human life is Buddha, all aspects of it…this is practicing the Dharma.

In his Rules for Meditation, Dogen tells us that training and enlightenment are one:  Since Truth (Dharma or enlightenment) is not separate from training, training is unnecessary—the separation will be as that between heaven and earth if even the slightest gap exists FOR, WHEN THE OPPOSITES ARISE, THE BUDDHA MIND IS LOST. However much
you may be proud of your understanding, however much you may be enlightened, whatever your attainment of wisdom and supernatural power, your finding of the way to mind illumination, your power to touch heaven and to enter into enlightenment, when the opposites arise you have almost lost the way to salvation.

“…when the opposites arise you have almost lost the way to salvation…”  Understanding that the real nature  of life is undivided, non-dual…this is practicing the Dharma.

The “undivided” life is the life of  practicing the Dharma.  When the mind is no longer dualistic it is in accord with circumstances. 

In Awakening the Mind of the Bodhisattva, Chapter 4 of the Shushogi, Dogen says:
If one can identify oneself with that which is not oneself, one can understand the true meaning of sympathy: take, for example, the fact that the Buddha appeared in the human world in the form of a human being; sympathy does not distinguish between oneself and others.  There are times when the self is infinite and times when this is true of others:  sympathy is as the sea in that it never refuses water from whatsoever source it may come; all waters may gather and form only one sea.

“…sympathy is as the sea in that it never refuses water from whatsoever source it may come; all waters may gather and form only one sea…” Understanding the interconnectedness of our human life, our human practice…this is practicing the Dharma.

Bodhidharma’s Fourth Practice  – practicing the Dharma builds on the preceding three – allowing injustice, sitting unmoved, seeking nothing.  All of these point us to the great opportunity we have to live our normal daily life as human beings, mindful and in the present moment, rooted in  Right Understanding.

The mind that is apart from things is the mind that likes and dislikes, grasps and rejects, loves and hates, Picks and chooses.  This is the mind that suffers.  This is the mind that is self-centered and separate.

Practicing being “at one with”,  practicing sympathy, this mind is not the suffering mind. Our self and our life are still there AND, in sympathy, in non-duality, we know the true interconnectedness of all things…there is harmony between inside and outside, self and other, subject and object.  Thus Bodhidharma can say there is no (impure) being, no (separate) self.  Our true self, our Buddha Nature, undivided, unstained.

We know that existence is not broken up into that which is pure and that which is defiled.  We a fundamental goodness in our Buddha Nature.  Rev. Master Daishin points out how we must utterly accept ourselves as we are to have a true understanding of this, and to do that we have to let go of the slightest move to defend ourselves or seek justification in the face
of truth.  We can be “wrong”.  We can be tired or crabby…because this very mind is Buddha.When greed, anger and delusion arise they are who we are…and we train and practice with them. This is practicing the Dharma.

In fact greed, anger and delusion are our teachers.  They have great value as our practice transforms them into compassion, loving-kindness and wisdom.  Being human is being human.  Being human fully, rooted in Right Understanding, is the practice of the Dharma.

RM Daishin Morgan says:  “An oak tree expresses itself fully as an oak tree.  Our existence seems more complicated than that, yet we too express ourselves fully as the beings that we are.  By looking into the expression of this moment we can appreciate what we have…

…by letting the dust be, its true nature is known.”

This is a most subtle seeing, one that we come to through experience.  Such experience does not come without our conscious engagement, which brings a very active dimension to our sitting.  It is true that our sitting is purposeless, and if we are seeking anything at all as we do it, we miss the point.  However, sitting is anything but a static or quietistic stillness,  sitting – our meditation –  is ceaseless practice and activity is implicit within it, and so our engagement is to discern the depths of this non-activity.  RM Daishin Yalon often points to stillness in activity and activity in stillness.  When we do this, busy as we may be, we are practicing the Dharma.

Bodhidharma talks about the Way of Enlightenment.  Thus, through their own practice they’re able to help others and glorify the Way of Enlightenment.  It is important to remember that, as RM Daishin Morgan says,  Enlightenment is not what you think…when we try to look within, our expectations become a barrier.  It is unrealistic to expect there to be no expectations  – we’re human – but we can learn to recognize them and see that investing in them only serves to obscure what we seek.  We can then begin to let expectation fade into unimportance.  Awakening begins when we learn to accept and deal with what is actually present, not matter what it is.

We’ve talked about the Three Marks in Buddhism – dukkha, anicca, anatta – suffering, the reality of change, and no-separate self.  These form the foundation of Right Understanding.  And Right Understanding, as part of the Eightfold Path, offers us a point of entry to come to appreciate the

interconnections of our “inner”  and “outer” worlds.  The Eightfold Path speaks directly to the connections between our understanding, our thinking, our speech, our action, our livelihood.

When we’re practicing the Dharma all things are our meditation cushion.  All thoughts, our words, our actions, our relationships…all things offer us the opportunity to carry out the ceremony of daily life.  Each person we meet is a sutras that we can learn from, and appreciate.  All things are Dharmas for us…all things are expressions of “the Truth”…

I read this in an earlier talk, but it bears repeating here, from Bonnie Myotai Treace: “… our emotions, disappointments, moods – every single dharma is a place we find our seat in practice. As always, this is simple, but its usually not easy. Though there is no pay-off, when we really commit to this, we may find that we’re no longer running a game, trying so hard to fix “one more matter” as he says, that we miss what’s right here: our lives. One another. The melt water raining off the roof now. And now is where everything is possible. Its the invocation to bring oneself and one another home every chance we get…That is the promise of sangha — a bond beyond performance or condition, yet not denying precepts and weather, the fact that life hurts, and we can hurt each other. Moment by moment, not an idea—a life. Let’s show up for it, honest, bare-hearted, regardless…”

This is Practicing the Dharma.

The Fourth Noble Truth offers the means of giving up craving through the steps of the Eightfold Path…Right Understanding and Right Thought (Prajna), Right Speech, Right Action, and Right Livelihood (Sila),  Right Effort, Right Mindfulness, and Right Concentration (Samadhi), each one of these steps an exploration in itself.

In his Fourth Practice Bodhidharma invites us to build on the three preceding practices.  May I suggest that these practices closely parallel the Eightfold Path in the practices they point to.

Allowing injustice points us to seeing things as they truly are, in particular, seeing The truth of dukkha, anicca, anatta.  When we allow injustice, when we see our karma, our karmic tendencies and the way they play out in our lives, when we allow injustice, we root ourselves in the Prajna or the Wisdom practices of the Eightfold Path:  Right Understanding and Right Thought.

Sitting unmoved points us to living with things as they truly are, not being caught up in fear, aversion and delusion and the cravings they give rise to, as well as looking at what our mind is doing, purifying our hearts before we act.  When we sit unmoved, we are grounded in the Morality or Sila practices of the Eightfold Path:  Right Speech, Right Action, and Right Livelihood.

Seeking of nothing points us to an awareness of the oneness of training and enlightenment and the fundamental non-duality of our practice, certainly, and of the way things are.  When we seek nothing, we practice moment-to-moment meditation in such a way that our life is our cushion, and we live from the Samadhi or the Meditation practices of the Eightfold Path:  Right Effort, Right Mindfulness, and Right Concentration.

Practicing the Dharma is living as a Buddha lives.  Buddha Nature naturally and spontaneously practices the Precepts.  The Precepts are the mindset of a Buddha. They are the speech of a Buddha.  They are the acts of a Buddha.  These are not externally imposed thou-shalt-nots, but rather wholesome outpourings of an awakened being that acts in accordance with our true nature.  An awakened being is not caught up with thoughts of stealing or not stealing, but effortlessly leads a life of spotless integrity.  Giving and charity are done without any thought of “myself” that is doing the giving…no manipulation, no agenda.  Awakened beings help others but without any concept of helping, thus there is the natural arising of compassion…the natural arising of Buddhahood.  As Bodhidharma says, Thus, through their own practice they’re able to help others and glorify the Way of Enlightenment.  And as with charity, they practice the other virtues to eliminate delusion, they practice nothing at all.  They simply are.

Dogen says in the Shushogi, Capter 3, Receiving the Precepts:  “…Within these Precepts dwell the Buddhas, enfolding all things within their unparallelled wisdom: there is no distinction between subject and object for any who dwell herein. All things, earth, trees, wooden posts, bricks, stones, become Buddhas once this refuge is taken. From these Precepts come forth such a wind and fire that all are driven into enlightenment when the flames are fanned by the Buddha’s influence: this is the merit of non-action and non-seeking; the awakening to True Wisdom…”  True Wisdom is the Dharma.  True Wisdom  is seeing things as they are.

Bodhidharma ends by referring to the virtues or Paramitas.  The practice of generosity – charity, morality or discipline, patience, energy or devotion, concentration or meditation, and wisdom—all of these are done without any concept of “myself” doing them.  Without any sense of “myself” practicing the Paramitas, Bodhidharma can say “they practice nothing at all.  This is what’s meant by practicing the Dharma…the natural and spontaneous outpouring of our Buddha Nature, of our true being.

Accepting injustice, sitting unmoved, seeking nothing, moment-by-moment meditation, keeping the precepts and doing what needs to be done, seeing things as they truly are…this is practicing the Dharma.
Chapter Five of the Shushogi is entitled Putting the Teachings into Practice and Showing Gratitude.  Another way of saying that might be Practicing the Dharma.  So let me close here with Dogen’s “reworking” of Bodhidharma’s Fourth Practice :

You need no further teachings than the above in order to show gratitude,
and you must show it truly, in the only real way, in your daily life;
our daily life should be spent constantly in selfless activity with no waste of time whatsoever.
Time flies quicker than an arrow and life passes with greater transience than dew…
The life of this one day, to-day, is absolutely vital life; your body is deeply significant.
Both your life and your body deserve love and respect
for it is by their agency that Truth
(Dharma) is practiced
and the Buddha’s power
(Dharma) exhibited:
the seed of all Buddhist activity, and of all Buddhahood,
is the true practice of Preceptual Truth
(Dharma) .

All the Buddhas are within the one Buddha Shakyamuni
and all the Buddhas of past, present and future become Shakyamuni Buddha
when they reach Buddhahood. This Buddha Nature
(Dharma) is itself the Buddha
and, should you awaken to a complete understanding thereof,
your gratitude to the Buddhas will know no bounds.

I offer the merit of this talk, in gratitude, to all beings
that we together may fully and gratefully practice “practicing the Dharma”

Homage to the Buddha.
Homage to the Dharma.
Homage to the Sangha.

1 Comment
Categories : Audio Dharma Talks, Class Series
Tags : Buddhism, Monastic Dharma talk, Practicing the Dharma, the Four Practices of Bodhidharma

Seeking Nothing by Rev. Helen Cummings

Posted by Pam Johnson 
· March 1, 2015 
· 1 Comment

The following text was written in preparation for an audio Dharma talk, the third of four talks given for the Bear River Meditation Group class series in February/March 2015 on The Four Practices of Bodhidharma. The audio file of Reverend Helen’s talk is available here. Reverend Helen is a Zen monk training at Shasta Abbey Buddhist Monastery. She will respond to questions and discussion on the talk during the class series. Please scroll down to the end of the text to post your questions in the “Leave a Comment/Reply” area.  Responses will be screened to eliminate spam and inappropriate language.

Seeking Nothing
by Reverend Helen Cummings

The third of Bodhidharma’s Four Practices is seeking nothing…the seeking of nothing or no seeking.

The Buddha’s Third Noble Truth – There IS a cessation to suffering – is simple logic. Once we understand the causes of suffering, then we can completely eliminate these causes and thus be free from suffering.  From his own experience, the Buddha taught that the cessation of suffering IS possible.  We simply have to give up its cause:  craving.

Bodhidharma, in his third practice – seeking nothing – underscores that we have all that we need in our practice, in our training, and points to how we can more fully live the Third Noble Truth.  We have no need for the judgments, the expectations or the delusions that comprise much of our thoughts.  We have no need, further, to maintain that greatest of illusions that we cherish and prop up the “self”.  Our life of practice is the expression of our fundamental Buddha Nature.  We become more fully human as we live our practice, not driven by, but rather transforming, the Three Poisons of fear, aversion, and delusion.

Bodhidharma says:

People of this world are deluded.
They’re always longing for something
– always, in a word, seeking.
But the wise wake up.
They choose reason over custom.
They fix their minds on the sublime
and let their bodies change with the seasons.
All phenomena are empty.
They contain nothing worth desiring.
“Calamity forever alternates with Prosperity”.
To dwell in the three realms is to dwell in a burning house.
To have a body is to suffer.
Does anyone with a body know peace?
Those who understand this
detach themselves from all that exists
and stop imaging or seeking anything.
The sutra says “To seek is to suffer.  To seek nothing is blissful.”
When you seek nothing, you’re on the path.”

People of this world are deluded.
And the “self” is a fundamental delusion.
Separation or a separate self is a fundamental delusion.
And that there is something to “achieve” in our practice is a fundamental delusion.

They’re always longing for something
To cherish and protect the “self”…
To maintain that separate self in its isolation…
To achieve “perfection – financially, emotionally, spiritually, in terms of the laundry – there are so many areas in which we seek perfection”
And we seek perfection in our practice all too often when we seek “good meditation” or an “enlightenment” experience or just plain peace…
– always, in a word, seeking.  

The definition of  “delusion”:  always longing for something –
always, in a word, seeking…

But the wise wake up.
The definition of “wake up”:  They choose reason over custom

Waking up moment by moment, choice by choice.
Enlightenment is moment by moment, choice by choice.

They choose reason over custom. 

“Custom” means “conditioning”
We can make choices that take us beyond our conditioning, karmic or otherwise
We can choose to “go against the grain” of our upbringing, of our education,  of our tendencies

They fix their minds on the sublime
“
the sublime” means “The One True Thing”

and let their bodies change with the seasons.
And they don’t resist the change that is inherent in this human realm

All phenomena are empty.
They contain nothing worth desiring.
We have nothing fixed to hold onto.  There is nothing the crave.

“Calamity forever alternates with Prosperity”.
“
Good news, bad news, who knows”

To dwell in the three realms is to dwell in a burning house.
“
three realms” of past, present, and future
“three realms of greed, hate, and delusion”
“the burning house” of our body, of our lives

To have a body is to suffer.
Does anyone with a body know peace?
And yet as Dogen also says:  …this body is deeply significant. It is this body that points us to the truths of anicca, dukkha, and anatta…and especially to the truth of non-duality:  through this body and its suffering, we come to an appreciation of our interconnectedness…in life and in death…

Those who understand this
detach themselves from all that exists
“
detach”  – yes! And we live in our bodies, we live in our own zip code, we live in our own present moment.  This is what being human is about, and this is where we train.  We detach from all that exists AND we live in the midst of it…unattached, appreciative, grateful for all the teaching that this immediate moment offers us

and stop imagining or seeking anything.
“
stop imagining” – give up our “story”, our “drama”
“seeking anything” – give up our “acting as if” or “grasping onto”

The sutra says “To seek is to suffer.  To seek nothing is blissful.”
To not have to be worried about outcomes or affirmations.

When you seek nothing, you’re on the path.”
Suffering injustice you have entered the path…
Adapting to conditions you silently follow the path…
Seeking nothing you are on the path…

The story of the Master who was asked by his disciple what he, the Master, did when he meditated.  The Master replied:  I don’t meditate.

But wait!  Don’t we come to training “seeking?   We study “the Mind that seeks the way”.  Our entry to practice starts by looking for happiness, peace, enlightenment, or at least some relief from difficulty, pain, suffering.  Seeking appears at first to be quite worthwhile, doesn’t it?  We begin to see, as Bodhidharma says, how “calamity forever alternates with prosperity”.  We begin to see how we are driven by fear or aversion or delusion.  And we begin to glimpse that First Noble Truth and its reality for us:  that we are never satisfied.

And, as we meditate and do the practice, as we seek and gain insights, we come to realize that it’s by not looking outside for “satisfaction…however we define it” that we find true peace and steadiness.  Rather it is through our meditation practice where we sit still, watch what our mind is doing, begin to see things as they truly are, begin to suffer injustice.

It is in our sitting that we adapt to conditions, that we choose  the “inner quiet” that is contentment in some situations, steadfastness in others…where we choose a mind that neither waxes nor wans, one that neither holds on nor pushes away.

And rooted in this very practice of seeking nothing.  It’s a practice that points us to our fundamental sufficiency.  Our very lives – as they are –  are an expression of Buddha Nature.  But how many of us truly see that? and how many of us really believe it?  Rev. Master Daishin Morgan observed that “…the ending of the delusion does not come … through seeking safety
in a belief in something outside or above this life.  Rather it is a matter of seeing into the nature of what our life already is…”

This is what Dogen is talking about, too, when he says that “…to study Buddhism is to study the self…”  We need to see into the nature of what our life already is.  This is a key part of seeking nothing.

Bodhidharma says it is only when we stop seeking satisfaction in outside phenomena that we can find the true treasures of our mind and our life.  We have what we are truly looking for already: This very mind IS Buddha.  Training and enlightenment ARE one.
Again to quote Rev. Master Daishin Morgan:  It is often rightly said that in order to awaken, we need to develop the mind that seeks the way.  This is the mind of things as they are, the mind that naturally responds to the need of the moment and does whatever needs to be done because it is alive and present.  The mind that seeks the way is not concerned with affirmations of itself.

Dogen, when he first came back from China, in Rules For Meditation, addressed the question of seeking nothing.  He asked:

Why are training and enlightenment differentiated since the Truth is universal?
Why study the means of attaining it since the supreme teaching is free?
Since Truth is seen to be clearly apart from that which is unclean, why cling to a means of cleansing it?

His answer is direct and to the point:
Since Truth is not separate from training, training is unnecessary—the separation will be as that between heaven and earth if even the slightest gap exists FOR, WHEN THE OPPOSITES ARISE, THE BUDDHA MIND IS LOST. However much you may be proud of your understanding, however much you may be enlightened, whatever your attainment of wisdom and supernatural power, your finding of the way to mind illumination, your power to touch heaven and to enter into enlightenment, when the opposites arise you have almost lost the way to salvation.

…no matter your achievement…when the opposites arise…Dogen is pointing us to the heart of our practice.  It isn’t about achievement.  It is going beyond the opposite to non-duality. Non-duality is the ground of sympathy.  This is what Honshin is talking about when he says:  When we look deeply into the other we find ourselves.  We are not separate.

What we commonly think of as the self is an illusion. It is nothing in itself at all but a name we give to our continuous interaction with the environment.  We constantly see, hear, smell, taste, touch, and think, and it is this cascade of sensations, perceptions and judgments, thought after thought, that we identify as the self.  It is not the separate and constant point of reference against which all time and events are marked.  It is an interconnected thread in the flow of samsaric existence.

To say that the self is an illusion, however, is not to say that the self is an hallucination.  The self is not a mirage.  We say that the self is illusory because it is not a stable entity but, rather, a series of events that are forever changing in response to constantly changing environment.

The practice of no seeking, seeking nothing, is the practice of no self.  Yes, it’s normal for people to begin to learn and practice Buddhism for their own benefit.  But eventually, through practice, our self-centeredness begins to fall away.  We find ourselves living the Three Pure Precepts:  We cease from evil.  We try to do only good.  And we try to do good for others, in particular by purifying our own hearts.

There is a shift to kindness, compassion, and loving-kindness.  There is a commitment to living the Four Wisdoms of charity, tenderness, benevolence and sympathy.  But NOT to achieve anything.  To quote the Metta Sutra, it’s because “…this is what should be done by one who is skilled in goodness and who knows the path of peace”.

There is a commitment to the Precepts, not because of the force of “thou shalt not” and the potential consequences of not complying, but rather because as we live more fully from our Buddha Nature, we begin to choose to act as Buddhas act.  Oddly enough, it becomes more natural to act in this way…and there is much less “wake”…

As the Offertory says in describing a venerable master:  “…he simply kept the Precepts and did what needed to be done…”.   Such a person no longer even thinks about attaining enlightenment.  He simply is training.  And he is practicing seeking nothing.

In our tradition enlightenment isn’t about walking on air or radiating glowing light in the dark.  It’s more about how patient we are in the face of frustration…it’s about how we live the Four Wisdoms.  To live a life of training is to live as an expression of enlightenment.  As Rev. Master Daishin Morgan says,  Training is not a means of acquiring enlightenment.

Dogen, in Gakudo Yojinshu, quite practically invites us to start the process:  …simply let go of the selfish self for a little…for a little.   How do we do this?

Let go of the wanting, the “gotta have it”s, the insistence.

Let go of the idea of perfection…and particularly the idea that “my way” is perfection.
Let go of the self…this fixed and constant being…this excellent functionary.  What happens, though, when “you” can’t function?  Can you let that “you” go?

Rev. Master Daishin Morgan asks some key questions:

If training and enlightenment are one, then enlightenment must be here and now, so where is it?…

and
…enlightenment still has to be realized.  So what are the implications for the path of training, if the goal is already here? 

His answer?  It is necessary that we sit still with great faith.  It takes a lot of faith not to follow our fears and desires and to choose to look into their heart instead.  The momentum that will carry us into awakening is already present within circumstances as they are.  

…We do not have to wait for any special circumstances or state of mind…

When we let go of self sufficiently to “suffer injustice”…to accept what arises in our meditation and in our lives, it involves much more than might at first sight be apparent.  Rev. Master Daishin Morgan says:  It is a thoroughly selfless response in which there can be no excuses, no seeking of reassurance, no blaming, no justification.  How can it be done?

…it is a matter of NOT doing it again and again, and keeping going
anyway with all the devotion one can find, doing the best sitting meditation one can.  And still it is not “done” …There is no achievement here that we can take away
…

In the practice of no seeking, we continually, diligently engage in useful activity, yet when we are seeking nothing, we have no thought that this activity is for our personal gain now or in the future. We do not look for personal benefits. This is not easy.   It’s a constant process of purifying our hearts:  why am I doing what I’m doing?

When Bodhidharma asks us to look at what our mind is doing, he is essentially asking us to seek nothing.  Are we judging?  Our judgments are a form of seeking.  Do we have expectations?  Expectations are a form of seeking.   Am I picking and choosing?  Our “pickings and choosings” are a form of seeking.  What is my mind doing in this moment?  How can I purify my heart in this moment.

A teacher said:
When you have ceased to be concerned about you own attainment,
then you are enlightened.  Otherwise there will always be subtle,
wandering thoughts and attachment to the desire to do something for yourself.  If you want to free yourself from all worldly vexations and suffering and if you desire liberation, you are still attached to your self.
It is only when you have no concern about your own enlightenment
that you can be truly enlightened.  The practice of no seeking is the practice of this enlightened state.

When asked what he did when he meditated, the master said:  I don’t meditate.

I offer the merit of this talk to all beings
that we together may fully and gratefully practice “seeking nothing”

Homage to the Buddha.
Homage to the Dharma.
Homage to the Sangha.

1 Comment
Categories : Audio Dharma Talks, Class Series
Tags : Buddhism, Monastic Dharma talk, Seeking Nothing, the Four Practices of Bodhidharma

Adapting to Conditions by Rev. Helen Cummings

Posted by Pam Johnson 
· February 23, 2015 
· 1 Comment

The following text was written in preparation for an audio Dharma talk, the second of four talks given for the Bear River Meditation Group class series in February/March 2015 on The Four Practices of Bodhidharma. The audio file of Reverend Helen’s talk is available here. Reverend Helen is a Zen monk training at Shasta Abbey Buddhist Monastery. She will respond to questions and discussion on the talk during the class series. Please scroll down to the end of the text to post your questions in the “Leave a Comment/Reply” area.  Responses will be screened to eliminate spam and inappropriate language.

Adapting to Conditions
by Reverend Helen Cummings

The second of Bodhidharma’s Four Practices is adapting to conditions, also given as sitting unmoved, or steadfast in the face of change.

The dictionary definition of “adapting” is “becoming adjusted to new conditions”.  But in Bodhidharma’s context,  “adapting” means acknowledging Anicca – one of the Three Characteristics of Buddhism.  Anicca – change.  All conditioned things change.  All aspects of our lives change, including this being that I call myself.   “Adapting to conditions” recognizes that there is a fundamental craving in us as humans that wants things to remain intact and unchanging, particularly when it come to ME and the way that I want me to be!

Adapting to conditions means sitting still – firmly – in the midst of change, not trying to hold onto something, not trying to “fix” a situation, not trying to make something permanent.

Adapting to conditions asks us to develop contentment with what we have, not being pulled by desire or pushed by craving.  We have what we need, in the circumstances that we are in. Craving is a kind of insistence on a very narrow view of self, a view of self as fixed, permanent. Craving is the acting on that view to protect the self in ways rooted in fear or in anger or in delusion.  Fundamentally, craving is cherishing the self.

In our contemporary world we are all too familiar with various kinds of addictions.  They are compulsive and they’re an intense form of craving, and they give us a clue about the less obvious graspings that mark our daily lives.  Addictions are fundamentally unpleasant, even when we are involved in the addictive activity itself, but they’re especially unpleasant as we deal with the consequences.  Pema Chodron offers us something to consider in this regard when she says, we are primarily addicted to ME.  But I offer that it’s the consequences of that addiction that bring us to practice.

The Buddha’s Second Noble Truth – suffering has a cause and that cause is our craving – is the ground on which Bodhidharma builds his second practice – when he asks us to look at how we respond to the conditions in our lives.

Bodhidharma takes us to a deeper understanding of that Second Noble Truth.   He tells us that the cause of the frustration and suffering that are the hallmarks of NOT “adapting to conditions” is the fact that we hold onto things that are changing, that we grasp after them when they are gone, and that we continue to be attached to them even as they are no longer there.  We want what we want, and we don’t want to let go.

We do not live with an understanding and awareness of anicca, we do not adapt to the change that is fundamental in this human realm.  The Diamond Sutra says it very powerfully:

Thus shall ye think of all this fleeting world:
a star at dawn, a bubble in a stream,
a flash of lightning, a child’s laugh, a phantasm, a dream.

When we know this we are adapting to conditions.

Adapting to conditions first and foremost requires us to “see things as they truly are”.  And anicca – change – is fundamental here.  Things change.  We cannot hold onto any thing, any one, not even our self.  We cannot grasp some one, some thing, no matter how precious, no matter how much we may want to.

The answer that the Buddha found to the cause of suffering is rooted in this:  craving. I want it this way! I want it otherwise! I want conditions to be different!   I want…

Bodhidharma asks other questions:
*   Can we truly see how we are driven by craving, restlessness, aversion, delusion?
*   Can we develop a steadfast heart, and strengthen our capacity to respond from that heart, from our “immovable” sitting place?
*   Can we hold anicca – seeing things as they truly are – Right Understanding as our “polar star” when we come to make choices in our daily life?

Let me read Bodhidharma’s words on “suffering injustice” as given by Red Pine:

As mortals we’re ruled by conditions not by ourselves.
All the suffering and joy we experience depend on conditions.
If we should be blessed by some great reward, such as fame and fortune,
it’s the fruit of a seed planted by us in the past.
When conditions change, it ends.
Why delight in its existence?
But while success and failure depend on conditions,
the mind neither waxes nor wans.
Those who remain unmoved by the wind of joy silently follow the path.

Before meeting the Dharma people live by reacting to circumstances.
Grasping what seems pleasurable, avoiding what seems unpleasant,
people strive to hold on to dependent pleasure and happiness.

As mortals we’re ruled by conditions not by ourselves.
The eight worldly conditions, the eight winds of change,
the eight topsy-turvy conditions, the flow of anicca is constant.

All the suffering and joy we experience depend on conditions.
And yet as we know from our talk last time,
“Conditions are not separate from the Way.”
When we see clearly, we know them for the teachers that they are.

If we should be blessed by some great reward, such as fame and fortune,
it’s the fruit of a seed planted by us in the past.
Karma…conditions today are the result of past choices, either in this life or in other lives…
and this is why our choice in each moment is so important.

When conditions change, it ends.
Why delight in its existence?
The Japanese poet says: I know this glass is already broken and so I enjoy it fully.

But while success and failure depend on conditions,
the mind neither waxes nor wans.
The steadfast mind is the mind of Achalanatha—”the immovable one”
And it’s important to remember here that Achalanatha, fierce as he is,
is an aspect of compassion.

Those who remain unmoved by the wind of joy silently follow the path.

Follow the path…having entered the path through the first practice of “suffering injustice”.

Before meeting the Dharma people live by reacting to circumstances.
Our practice results in our strengthened capacity to make choices that reflect
responses rooted in the mind of meditation, rooted in the steadfast mind,
rather than karmically-driven or automatic-pilot reactions.

Grasping what seems pleasurable, avoiding what seems unpleasant,
people strive to hold on to dependent pleasure and happiness.
However, circumstances are impermanent
and there is no way people can make circumstances
always, eternally, provide their happiness.
Don’t we know this to be true as we live our contemporary, market-driven lives!

The advice that Dilgo Khyentse Rinpoche and Padampa Sangye gave to the “People of Tingri” in The Hundred Verse of Advice (#74), is valuable for us as well.  They say:

“Your notions of the outer world derive from the mind within;
People of Tingri, let the solid ice be melted into liquid.”

“Lakes and rivers can freeze in winter and the water can become so solid that people, animals, and carts travel back and forth on its surface.  At the approach of spring, the earth warms up and the waters thaw.  What remains then of all that solid ice?  Water is soft and fluid, ice hard and sharp.  We cannot say that they are identical, but neither are they different—ice is only frozen water, and water is only melted ice.

It is the same with our perceptions of the external world.  To be attached to the reality of phenomena, tormented by attraction and repulsion, and obsessed by the eight worldly conditions is what causes the mind to freeze.  Melt the ice of your concepts so that the fluid water of free perceptions can flow.”

“Melt the ice of your concepts…” …this is another way of saying “adapt to conditions” Doesn’t it apply particularly well when we think of  the “ice” of our own fixed self, and of the ways that we entrench ourselves,  and ways we insist on cherishing and protect it?

When we are “frozen” – unadapting in our responses to the conditions in our lives – what actually hurts is not that we don’t have something.  It is that we don’t have it and we want it frozen in place.  What causes grief is not that we lose something.  It is that we are unable to accept the fact and let the water flow.

The “melting” that is “adapting to conditions” is when we change how we relate to the world around us in light of Right Understanding. Anicca tells us that everything is always changing…when we know this, we know Right Understanding:  The conditions we wish to maintain and “fix” will change, as will the unpleasant conditions we can all too easily believe will last forever.  If we can just find a way to give up our grabbing onto things, to find a way to accept life as it actually is, truly adapt to conditions, we’ll be able to be steadfast in the face of the inevitable changes in our lives.

RM Daizui  puts its succinctly:  Realizing all of this…makes clear that our never-ending desires to make the world “behave itself” in the way we wish cannot possibly lead us to anything other than self-frustration.

When we know this, we have a glimpse of a whole other way of being:  where we can accept anicca, where we can be at home with the flow of change of things.

It doesn’t mean we don’t enjoy things, experiences, friends, family.  But we do it in the spirit of the Japanese poem:  I know this glass is already broken, and so I enjoy it fully! Yes, take full advantage of the joy…don’t hold on, don’t push away.

Our meditation practice is so important in “adapting to conditions”.  Although it takes all we have to stay seated for the meditation, we generally don’t bound off our cushion when things get difficult in our meditation.  Those difficulties are simply the conditions of the moment and we let them arise, abide, and pass away.  This is why a regular meditation practice is so important, even if it is only 5 minutes each day.  This is the cultivation of a steadfastness that we can bring into other areas of life when we choose to “adapt to conditions”.  We can let “those” situations benefit from our ability to let things arise, abide, and pass away.

Our sitting meditation isn’t about getting it right or achieving some ideal state.  It’s really about being able to stay present with ourselves.  It’s about learning how to realize – make real –  the Invocation to Achalanatha in our own lives.  The Invocation says:  “May we within the temple of our own hearts dwell amidst the myriad mountains”.  The “myriad mountains” can be considered the myriad conditions in which we live and work.  “Dwelling” in the temple of our own hearts means “sitting unmoved” in the example of Achalanatha Bodhisattva, Fudo, the Immovable One.

In asking us to adapt to conditions, Bodhidharma asks us to deepen our awareness of the True Nature of conditioned things, and to strengthen our commitment to the One True Thing.  When we root ourselves more firmly in our meditation practice—our immovable sitting place that is available to us not just in the meditation hall, but in all arenas of our life and work – when we do that, we keep a steady mind, one that is not swayed by circumstances.

“Adapting to conditions”, we choose  the “inner quiet” that is contentment in some situations, steadfastness in others…we choose a mind that neither waxes nor wans.

I offer the merit of this talk to all beings
that we together may fully and gratefully “adapt to conditions”
Homage to the Buddha.
Homage to the Dharma.
Homage to the Sangha.


1 Comment
Categories : Audio Dharma Talks, Class Series
Tags : Adapting to Conditions, Buddhism, Monastic Dharma talk, the Four Practices of Bodhidharma

Suffering Injustice by Rev. Helen Cummings

Posted by Pam Johnson 
· February 16, 2015 
· 18 Comments

The following text was written in preparation for an audio Dharma talk, the first of four talks given for the Bear River Meditation Group class series in February/March 2015 on The Four Practices of Bodhidharma. The audio file of Reverend Helen’s talk is available here. Reverend Helen is a Zen monk training at Shasta Abbey Buddhist Monastery. She will respond to questions and discussion on the talk during the class series. Please scroll down to the end of the text to post your questions in the “Leave a Comment/Reply” area.  Responses will be screened to eliminate spam and inappropriate language.

Suffering Injustice
by Reverend Helen Cummings

Bodhidharma’s Outline of Practice—written nearly 1500 years ago— describes two essential doors that lead to the Path.  One is the entryway of reason. The second is the entryway of practice and it this doorway that I will be exploring in this talk and the three that follow. The entryway of practice provides us with four  “all-inclusive” practices that have relevance to our contemporary life and training.

The First Practice is suffering injustice, also translated as acceptance of suffering or accepting karmic retribution.  “Suffering” in this sense is familiar to those who have grown up with the King James translation of the Bible and Luke 18:  Suffer the little children to come unto me…  It means allow or permit or not  get in the way of.  So when we “suffer injustice” we allow it to be…in our awareness, in our practice, in our life.

Let me read Bodhidharma’s words on “suffering injustice” as given by Red Pine:

When those who search for the path
encounter adversity,
they should think to themselves
“in countless ages gone by I’ve turned
from the essential to the trivial
and wandered through all manner of existences,
often angry without cause
and guilty of numberless transgressions.
Now, though I do no wrong,
I am punished by my past.
Neither gods not men can foresee
when an evil deed will bear it’s fruit.
I accept it with an open heart
and without complaint of injustice”
The sutra says “when you meet with adversity don’t be upset,
because it makes sense.”
With such understanding you’re in harmony with reason.
And by suffering injustice you enter the path.”

The Buddha’s First Noble Truth is fundamental: Dukkha – suffering – dissatisfaction – exists. Bodhidharma’s First Practice invites us to a deeper relationship with this First Noble Truth, to a deeper understanding of what our suffering teaches us in our practice, as well as to a deeper understanding of how we relate to that suffering.

“Suffering injustice” might also be translated as “acknowledging the existence of the unpleasant”, or as  “allowing that which we don’t like to be in our consciousness (or in our lives!) without knee-jerk-aversive reactions”.  This, too is fundamental in our tradition. Dogen, in the Shobogenzo chapter called “Yuibutsu Yobutsu, tells us  “The determination to see things as they truly are, free from preconceived notions, results in the emergence of true practice…” This “seeing clearly” is at the heart of “suffering injustice”

Can we truly see the suffering–injustice—adversity in our lives – and allow it to be there without holding onto it or pushing it away?

Can we truly see what choices we make in our minds, in our speech, and in our actions as
we respond to that suffering–injustice—adversity ?

Can we truly see the places where we can choose to change our relationship to the
suffering–injustice—adversity as we deepen our practice?

But perhaps a good place to start is with the heartfelt questions that all of us have asked again and again: why is this happening to me, and why is this happening to me NOW?  How do I avoid it?  Change it?  Get rid of it?

The Buddha sought to answer the questions prompted by the Four Sights – an old man, a sick man, a dead man, and a monk.  In the context of this talk, may I propose we might consider them the Four Injustices or the Four Adversities.  As he considered these Sights, the Buddha allowed himself – perhaps for the first time in his privileged life – to “see” – actually see – the suffering inherent – though not acknowledged – in his daily life.

Dukkha is one of the Three Characteristics of Buddhism.  Bodhidharma’s first practice – recognizes that dukkha exists for each of us, from the minor dissatisfactions of our normal work and family days to the truly horrific experiences that may confront us, either personally or globally on the nightly news.  And this arises because our the way our mind works.

The “normal” approach to suffering or dissatisfaction or even just boredom is that we flee uncomfortable situations and the painful feelings.  Bodhidharma is asking us to go against the grain in our relationship to those very things that we are conditioned, karmically and otherwise, to push away.

Can we allow the seeing injustice to simply “be there” and not react to it…not react from the emotions, thoughts or pain that it engenders in us?  Can we allow it to exist in our experience, but not being driven by it?  This is what we do in meditation, isn’t it? sitting with no deliberate thought, letting what comes up arise, abide, pass away…no matter how painful.  This is why meditation is so important as we commit to this practice of “suffering injustice”.  When we sit, we build our “suffering injustice” muscle.

How many of us find ourselves thinking: I do not want this to be happening…pushing away, denying, ignoring, the difficulty around us?

How many of us have echoed Star Trek’s Captain Kirk to implore:  “Beam me outta here, Scotty!”  when confronted with a hurtful situation, an unpleasant person, the dreadful diagnosis or that painful emotion?

How often do we close our eyes and one way or another affirm: “I do not want this karma, I demand something else.” We may not like “it”, but we can make space for it without acting on our likes and dislikes.  As Kanshi Sosan has said:  The Great Way is not difficult.  Just give up picking and choosing.  Just by not giving in to hatred and craving will your heart and mind be as clear and bright as the realm beyond the opposites.”  Just giving up picking and choosing is a form of  “suffering injustice”.

It is exactly when we are willing to be still and accept the difficult or the painful – when we can suffer injustice, allowing ourselves to recognize it for what it is and not try to avoid it – that we enter the Path.  And aren’t we searching for that very Path?

This does not mean we do not strive to change the things we can.  We do.  But we do it in a way that arise our clarity of vision.   We see what is truly in front of us, leaving aside our judgments, our aversions, our insistences. We see that “That person’s” behavior is not my responsibility.  “That person’s”  reaction is not something I can control.  And the universe is NOT answerable to my personal will.

Suffering does not flow into us from the pain and difficulty. It arises out of our delusion where we identify ourselves with what we think, what we feel, and then are driven to escape.

The meditative mind which recognizes that the endless flow of thoughts and feelings have
no fundamental reality is the mind that suffers injustice.

So what is our mind doing?  Generally our  “states” of mind – worry, pride, despair, fear, envy, desire – have us running from each of the traditional “six worlds:  heaven, hell, that of the hungry ghosts, that of the asuras, the animal realm, and every once in a while, the human realm.

Our practice invites us to go beyond this constant whirlwind, “stopping” to be fully present and aware of where we are right now, what we have right now. The story we weave of our past and future is problematic. The past is a memory we are grasping and repeating to ourselves and the future is a tale we are telling ourselves of what might be.

When we “suffer injustice” we see what is right in front of us, here and now.  When we are clear about the actual conditions we are in, we can respond more preceptually, more compassionately, perhaps even more effectively.  When we fully accept our present
experience, instead dreaming of a future that either entices or frightens us and dreaming of a past that we cannot let go, we are sitting on our cushion in our place of practice.  This IS the emergence of true practice.

“Injustice” is seeing within a narrow perspective and making judgments from that
perspective
.  It is seeing with blinders.  Bodhidharma invites us to broaden our perspective, reminding us that we are reaping the karmic results of past lives?  “Past lives” is a broad topic, but for now may I suggest that “past lives” be understood as “past choices”, whether in this life or otherwise.  So can we understand that we are reaping the “karmic” results of past choices?

“Karmic results” are not retribution, nor are they punishment. Karmic results are simply consequences of our choices.   If we choose to step off the roof of a 12 story building, the consequences of that choice simply accord with the laws of gravity.

By patiently accepting results from the past simply as results of our previous choices -and not punishment by an angry God or retribution from long-standing enemies – we don’t have to react emotionally to them.  We no longer “have to” react to them with anger or craving.  We can respond responsibility, perceptually, compassionately.

When we look in this way, we can more clearly see the consequences of our actions.  When we look in this way, we can make more information and responsive choices about our mind, our speech, our actions.  When we look this way, we can begin to change our relationship to “injustice” or adversity or suffering. Misfortunes will arise, but we do not have to be knocked off balance by them.  We can find a kind of equanimity, perhaps, or an acceptance, and even perhaps gratitude…we can choose to NOT be  resentful.  We can choose NOT to  suffer from disturbing emotions or be discouraged or depressed.  We can observe them without having to act on them.

“Seeing” and accepting karma in those patterns and tendencies is itself  the process of “cleansing karma”.  When we come to see our karmic patterns and tendencies we can see more clearly how karma affects our choices and how our choices affect our karma

Whether it is the fruition of karma in this life, or fruition of karma from past lives – when we can allow it to “be there” we may see our situation more clearly, more fully…and this is a doorway to understanding and acceptance, to the liberation of knowing that you can’t change others nor bend them to your will…

No, the universe is NOT answerable to my personal will!  And there’s nothing you have to prove!

We cannot – and should not – run away from our responsibilities and our karma. AND we should try to improve our conditions and karma,  If a situation can be improved, try to make it better.  If conditions can’t be changed, then we should accept them, understanding, as it says in the Scripture of Brahma’s Net, that  “Conditions are not separate from the Way.” And here, too, it is important to look at what our mind is doing.  Is our desire to change
things arising from a selfish sense of what should be?  Is our desire to change things rooted
in propping up our own sense of self?  Are we truly keeping the third of the Three Pure
Precepts:  Do good for others?  The alternate reading of that Precept is:  Purify one’s heart.  Let us not deceive ourselves.  Let us not deceive others.  Let us look at what our minds are
doing.

So yes, we do we have the opportunity to “suffering injustice”  – to cleanse our karma – in our daily lives.  There are the obvious things:

-competition and preference, in work, in love, even in practice
-perceived loss, material, emotional, psychological, even spiritual

-in fact, the “eight worldly conditions” apply to all aspects of our lives:

-gain and loss
-fame and disgrace
-praise and blame
-elation and sorrow

There are also the less obvious ones, less obvious but perhaps more corrosive:
-boredom, a form of anger, a form of rejection, wanting things to be different

-our insistence that we can change the people around us – they do what they do

-our insistence that we are responsible for others’ reactions…
-to say nothing of the weather, or our computers…
“Conditions are not separate from the Way.”  These very conditions – injustices –
adversities—are entryways to the path.

Myotai Sensei offered a reflection on Dogen’s words that I’ve found helpful.  He says: “… our emotions, disappointments, moods – every single dharma is a place we find
our seat in practice. As always, this is simple, but its usually not easy. Though there
is no pay-off, when we really commit to this, we may find that we’re no longer running a game, trying so hard to fix “one more matter” as he says, that we miss what’s right here: our lives. One another. The melt water raining off the roofnow. And now is where everything is possible. Its the invocation to bring oneself and one another home every chance we get…That is the promise of sangha — a bond beyond performance or condition, yet not denying precepts and weather, the fact that life hurts, and we can hurt each other. Moment by moment, not an idea—a life. Let’s show up for it, honest, bare-hearted, regardless…

So can we remember the Invocation to Achalanatha and consciously live “…within the temple of our own hearts…”?

Can we make our choices from the mind of meditation, seeing what our mind is doing?  Letting go of judgments and expectations?  Fears of the past?  Fears of the future?

Can we practice suffering injustice, acceptance of suffering, “acknowledging the existence of the unpleasant”, or as  “allowing that which we don’t like to be in our consciousness (or in our lives!) without knee-jerk-aversive reactions”?

So – in closing –  Bodhidharma’s words on the Practice of Suffering:

When those who search for the path
encounter adversity,
they should think to themselves
“in countless ages gone by I’ve turned
from the essential to the trivial
and wandered through all manner of existences,
often angry without cause
and guilty of numberless transgressions.
Now, though I do no wrong,
I am punished by my past.
Neither gods not men can foresee
when an evil deed will bear it’s fruit.
I accept it with an open heart
and without complaint of injustice”
The sutra says “when you meet with adversity don’t be upset,
because it makes sense.”
With such understanding you’re in harmony with reason.
And by suffering injustice you enter the path.”

Rev. Master Jiyu has said:  All-acceptance is the key to the gateless gate.

Kanchi Sosan has said:  The Great Way is not difficult.  Just give up picking and choosing.

Bodhidharma is telling us that by seeing injustice – suffering – for what it is, and by changing our relationship to it, we are not driven by it.  We enter the Path, acting perceptually, acting compassionately, living from a place of acceptance and gratitude


I offer the merit of this talk to all beings
that we together may fully and gratefully “suffer injustice”
Homage to the Buddha.
Homage to the Dharma.
Homage to the Sangha.

18 Comments
Categories : Audio Dharma Talks, Class Series
Tags : Buddhism, Monastic Dharma talk, Suffering Injustice, the Four Practices of Bodhidharma
Bear River Meditation Group
Copyright © 2025 All Rights Reserved
iThemes Builder by iThemes
Powered by WordPress